Rediscovering Gagné's Conditions of Learning ID Model

Photo by Kyle Glenn via Wix media

While searching for a refreshing instructional design (ID) model different from the most commonly used ones like ADDIE and Kirkpatrick, I stumbled upon Robert Gagné's Conditions of Learning. Gagné's learning model piqued my interest, particularly due to my focus on corporate training and development. It integrates an attractive approach to help learners achieve desired outcomes through what he called the nine instructional events: (1) Gain attention, (2) State objectives, (3) Stimulate recall, (4) Present the content, (5) Provide guidance, (6) Elicit performance, (7) Provide feedback, (8) Assess performance, and (9) Enhance transfer and retention (Gagné et al., 1992, as cited in Tough 2012).

(However, I won't delve deeper into each of these nine events in this blog post, as it would require writing a lengthy piece. Instead, my intention here is to share my thoughts and opinions on various topics rather than summarize what people can easily find online. I will provide some useful links at the bottom for those interested in further reading.)

In short, Gagné's model offers step-by-step learning frameworks designed to keep learners engaged throughout the entire process, ensuring the development of knowledge and skills applicable to real-world scenarios (Gagné, 1985). Additionally, this model reinforces learning by allowing learners to make mistakes and stimulates the connection of pre-existing knowledge with new information (Gagné, 1985, as cited in Tough 2012). It applies to both educational and corporate environments, making it a model I can envision implementing in adult education due to its flexibility for learners and instructors alike.

Gagné's Conditions of Learning and the nine instructional events are crafted to progressively allow learners to take ownership of their learning process with constant guidance from their mentors (Gagné, 1985, as cited in Tough 2012). This instructional approach, known as scaffolding in instructional design and education, involves breaking down learning content into manageable chunks or, in this case, structured methods to achieve learning outcomes. While this may resemble other ID models, Gagné's model stands out for its user-friendly approach that prioritizes the learner's best interests at every stage of the nine events, offering a more observational and guided approach to learning.

The nine instructional events are structured sequentially, beginning with event 1) Gain attention, which aims to capture the learners' interest in a friendly manner, such as through storytelling or presenting media content with examples of how the learning will be approached and its potential benefits (Gagné, 1985, as cited in Tough 2012). It then progresses towards communicating the goals of the course/training/lesson to the learner without delving into technicalities like Bloom's taxonomy. Instead, the learning is conveyed in a language tailored to the learners' age group and education level. However, the instructor should conduct the instruction based on clearly established goal objectives and serve as a guide throughout the learning process, culminating in helping learners relate and apply the acquired knowledge to real-life situations.

Now, let's delve into the distinctions between instructional design models and theoretical models. While theoretical models focus on evaluating and understanding learning from psychological, sociological, and cognitive standpoints, instructional design models offer a more structured approach to guided step-by-step learning procedures. From this perspective, Gagné's ID model can be approached from any theoretical model (e.g., constructivism and behaviorism), highlighting instructional design models as channels for implementing theoretical frameworks.

These differences between ID and theoretical models are essential to distinguish when designing learning plans, primarily from the instructional designer and instructor/teacher/trainer side, as they lay the foundation for how learning will be imparted to an audience. Moreover, this distinction between theoretical and instructional design models helps determine the cognitive and technical strategies needed to ensure knowledge transfer and retention.

In summary, Robert Gagné's Conditions of Learning model proves highly adaptable and effective for learning development when utilized correctly. However, it's crucial to recognize the difference between instructional design and theoretical models to determine the most suitable instructional strategies for the desired audience and learning outcomes. As instructional designers, we have access to various ID models to transform concepts into organized learning schemes that cater to diverse learners—an uplifting realization.

Resources

[Blade]. (2022, October 14). Gagne's Nine Events of Instruction with Examples | Micro-Lecture [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBdfqugeDgM

Gagné, R. The Conditions of Learning and Theory of Instruction, 4th ed. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1985.

Gagné, R., L. J. Briggs, and Wager. Principals of Instructional Design, 4th ed. Fort Worth, Texas: Harcourt Brace, 1992.

Peck, D. (2023, May 5). How to Apply Gagne's 9 Events of Instruction. Delvin Peck. https://www.devlinpeck.com/content/gagnes-nine-events-of-instruction

Tough, D. (2012). A Focus on Robert Gagné's Instructional Theories: Application to Teaching Audio Engineering. MEIEA Journal, 12(1), 209-220. https://libproxy.library.unt.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/focus-on-robert-gagnés-instructional-theories/docview/1518285846/se-2